GTA 6 a flop? 7 flaws even the 99 reviews call out
Everyone is talking about the 99 on Metacritic. We read the reviews all the way through to find what doesn't work.
Status: ✅ Official (flaws taken from reviews published on November 18, 2026 and from first player reports; checked around 5 pm ET)
Let's be clear right away: GTA 6 is not a flop. It holds a 99 on Metacritic, and when Dot Esports checked, no critic review was mixed or negative. But even reviewers handing out 10/10 list real flaws. And on X, one player has already called it the biggest disappointment in gaming history, which kicked off a heated debate. Here are the 7 complaints that come up most.
1. 30 frames per second, even on PS5 Pro
This is complaint number one. GTA 6 runs at 30 fps on PS5, PS5 Pro and Xbox Series X|S, with no 60 fps performance mode. Rockstar confirmed it in its November 10 Newswire post, citing the density of the world and visual fidelity. French outlet jeuxvideo.com points out that this console generation was supposed to be the 60 fps generation, and noticed light frame drops in big open-world shootouts, even on PS5 Pro. VGC saw slowdowns in the densest areas but calls them rare.
For context: GTA 5 also ran at 30 fps in 2013 and only hit 60 on PS5 and Xbox Series years later. Red Dead Redemption 2 never got a 60 fps mode on console.
2. A slow start and drawn-out moments
Several reviews find the story takes its time: it spends a long stretch on Jason and Lucia's home life before the big criminal jobs, and some missions drag with long conversations, according to Dot Esports' roundup. French site Journal du Geek adds that some activities take as long as they would in real life, which slows progress. VGC puts the main story at around 60 hours.
3. Combat lags behind the rest
GamingBolt, after close to 100 hours, found smaller firearms clunky. Melee is rated below driving and gunplay. Push Square dislikes the heavily armored bullet-sponge enemies near the end. Journal du Geek also notes the dodge roll is gone, while The Verge and The Guardian mention complex controls and some frustrating situations.
4. Softer satire
The most surprising complaint for a GTA game. Journal du Geek feels the series' parody edge is missing, with more realistic characters and humor that leans too much on sex. Other reviews find some jokes dated or crude.
5. A map that isn't always used
jeuxvideo.com lists uninspired gang camps and exploration that isn't always rewarded among its cons. Dot Esports also notes that large chunks of the map are never touched by the story.
6. Pushy wanted system and small bugs
The wanted and heat systems can feel overbearing, according to G2A's review summary, along with minor AI, physics and pop-in issues, plus rubberbanding in races.
7. A bumpy launch already
On Wednesday, thousands of PlayStation players reported trouble signing in to PSN, with about 876 Downdetector reports around 1 pm ET, Newsweek reports. In New Zealand, the first country to play, streamer N3ON first got a syncing message and then a temporary network problem on Xbox, according to Sportskeeda. So far, Yahoo hasn't seen widespread glitch reports from early players.
What's solid, what isn't
| Information | Level |
|---|---|
| 30 fps on every console, no 60 fps mode | ✅ Confirmed by Rockstar |
| Pacing, combat, satire: flagged by several reviews | ✅ Confirmed (multiple outlets) |
| PSN sign-in problems on Nov 18 | ✅ Confirmed (Newsweek, Downdetector) |
| "Biggest disappointment in history" | ❓ One player's opinion, widely disputed |
| 60 fps mode later | ❓ Nothing announced |
What it means for you
If smooth frame rate matters most to you, 30 fps is the one thing to know before buying. The rest are pacing and handling issues, not game-breaking problems. The unlock is still tonight at midnight local time, see our GTA 6 reviews: 99 on Metacritic article for all the scores.
Our take
A 99 doesn't mean zero flaws. Critics agree on the world, the direction and the sound, and the complaints are the same across outlets: frame rate, pacing and combat. We'll update this page with what we see in-game starting tomorrow.
FAQ
Is GTA 6 a flop?
No. It sits at 99 on Metacritic with no negative critic review as of November 18. The criticism is about specific points.
Does GTA 6 run at 60 fps on PS5 Pro?
No. It runs at 30 fps on every console, PS5 Pro included, and no 60 fps mode has been announced.
What are GTA 6's flaws?
Reviews mostly cite 30 fps, a slow start, weaker combat, softer satire and exploration that isn't always rewarded.
Does 30 fps bother you, or not at all?
Sources
- Dot Esports: GTA 6 review roundup
- ThePCEnthusiast: GTA 6 Reviews, praise and problems
- G2A News: what critics agree on
- Push Square: GTA 6 Review (PS5)
- jeuxvideo.com: GTA VI review (French)
- Journal du Geek: GTA 6 review (French)
- Beebom: GTA 6 performance mode
- Newsweek: PlayStation users report access issues
- Sportskeeda: N3ON in New Zealand
- IBTimes UK: the "biggest disappointment" debate
Independent site, not affiliated with Rockstar Games.
Commentaires
Enregistrer un commentaire